Great Britain & Ireland’s comeback from a 9.5-6.5 deficit following the Sunday morning foursome matches to pull out a 13.5-12.5 victory and claim the Walker Cup for the first time in nearly a decade had to be seen to be believed.
And since I didn’t see it, I’m still not sure I believe it.
I headed to Stonewall for a Sunday morning loop fairly certain that the United States, under captain Nathan Smith, the match-play maestro from Pittsburgh, was well on its way to a sixth straight victory in the Walker Cup Match at Lahinch Golf Club in County Clare on the Republic of Ireland’s scenic west coast.
The U.S. had just completed a dominant sweep of the foursome matches to turn a 6.5-5.5 deficit into a three-point lead. The U.S. never dominates foursomes, well hardly ever.
They were so focused and looked so determined.
Symbolic of their domination was the scud missile Oklahoma State senior Preston Stout, the No. 1 player in the World Amateur Golf Ranking (WAGR) dropped three feet from the hole at the 257-yard, par-4 13th hole with a freaking driver.
Stout’s partner and Oklahoma State teammate Ethan Fang, No. 9 in the WAGR, easily converted the eagle try and the two Cowboys were on their way to a 3 and 2 victory over Irishman Stuart Grehan, the winner of the Royal & Ancient’s Amateur Championship earlier this summer at the Royal Liverpool Golf Club and No. 28 in the WAGR, and Englishman Eliot Baker, No. 13 in the WAGR.
The U.S. has historically been stronger in singles than the unfamiliar alternate-shot foursomes format. So, when the Red, White & Blue dominated the foursomes Sunday morning, it seemed possible that our boys could play average golf in the singles and still pull this thing out.
I got home from my loop just in time to see GB&I celebrating an unlikely comeback and a Walker Cup victory. Hey, I have Irish roots. We know how to celebrate.
GB&I, under captain David Robertson, completely flipped the script.
I mentioned following Day 1 of this 51st Walker Cup Match that this felt different than the last five editions that the Americans had won.
GB&I had won the Saturday morning foursomes, 3.5-2.5, and split the eight Saturday singles matches to take a 6.5-5.5 lead into Day 2.
It just looked like the U.S. trusted its considerable talent in the Sunday morning foursomes. Surely, that wasn’t going to go away over a bite of lunch.
The main thing that was different about this GB&I team was its talent, particularly its depth of talent. Following the Sunday morning wipeout, GB&I didn’t get mad, it got even, in a big way.
The anatomy of a comeback like this always begins at the beginning. You have to pile up some early wins. In addition to earning you points, it gives you belief.
Grehan, the Irishman who had been so good in earning a point-and-a-half for GB&I Saturday, went out and defeated the No. 1 amateur player in the world in Stout, 2 and 1. Game on.
Englishman Luke Poulter, a senior at Florida and No. 8 in the WAGR, did his best imitation of his dad, U.S. Ryder Cup nemesis Ian Poulter, in a 3 and 1 victory over Fang.
Thought maybe Robertson under-utilized Englishman Jack Whaley, No. 45 in the WAGR, after he got on a serious roll to capture the U.S. Amateur at Merion Golf Club’s historic East Course last month.
Maybe the Florida State standout thought so, too, as he dismantled a pretty good player in Alabama sophomore William Jennings, the runnerup in the NCAA Championship at the Omni La Costa Resort & Spa in Carlsbad, Calif. in the spring and No. 4 in the WAGR, with an 8 and 7 beatdown.
Whaley’s fellow Seminole and fellow Englishman, Tyler Weaver, No. 3 in the WAGR, despite being sidelined for much of the summer with injury, rolled to a 4 and 3 victory over Stanford junior Jay Leng Jr., the runnerup to Whaley at Merion and No. 12 in the WAGR.
Suddenly, GB&I had a 10.5-9.5 lead and the golf-mad Irish fans, stunned into silence in the morning, were seeing some blood in the water.
Brigham Young sophomore Kihei Akina, No. 11 in the WAGR, temporarily stopped the bleeding by battling Englishman Niall Sheils Donegan, a senior at North Carolina and No. 18 in the WAGR, to a draw, earning the U.S. a half-point.
But then Baker, like Sheils Donegan, like Graham, a veteran of GBI’s loss to the U.S. in the Walker Cup Match a year ago at The Cypress Point Club, the iconic Alister Mackenzie layout on northern California’s Monterey Peninsula, birdied the par-5 18th hole to edge Stewart Hagestad, the 35-year-old veteran of all five of the most recent Walker Cup wins for the U.S., 1-up.
It’s been 10 years since Hagestad won the first of his three U.S. Mid-Amateur crowns at Stonewall. He has been a stalwart on the U.S. Walker Cup team, compiling a 7-1 record in singles before falling to Baker.
And maybe with his defeat, the air of invincibility for the U.S. side was suddenly gone.
In the back end of the lineup, the U.S. was pulling out a pair of victories as Oklahoma senior Ryder Cowan, No. 6 in the WAGR, closed out Englishman Ben Bolton, No. 86 in the WAGR, 3 and 2, and Auburn senior Josiah Gilbert, No. 7 in the WAGR, bounced back from a tough go Saturday with a 4 and 3 victory over Englishman Sam Easterbrook, a senior at Purdue and No. 76 in the WAGR.
The U.S. had 12 points with only 13 needed to retain the Walker Cup with a draw.
But the talented teens for the U.S., Miles Russell, the 17-year-old who is No. 5 in the WAGR, and Tyler Watts, the 18-year-old who is No. 2 in the WAGR, couldn’t get the visitors across the finish line.
Scotland’s Connor Graham, a junior at Texas Tech and No. 26 in the WAGR, was one of the leaders of this GB&I team, despite being only 19. He was the youngest player to tee it up in a Walker Cup Match ever when he represented GB&I at the Old Course at St. Andrews in his native Scotland at just 16 in 2023.
Graham made back-to-back birdies on the 17th and 18th holes to earn an all-important half-point for GBI by getting a draw with Russell. Each team had 12.5 points.
It was left to Englishman Josh Hill, one of the least-heralded members of the GBI team, to play the hero.
Hill wrapped up his career at Tennessee in the spring. The Volunteers can barely stand the wait as Watts is about to join their program.
But it was Hill who had the answer on the 18th hole at Lahinch. He blasted it out of a bunker in front of the par-5 finishing hole to three feet and rolled in the birdie putt to edge Watts, 1-up, and set off a wild celebration.
Let’s face it, GB&I was due. It had one of its most talented rosters and the home-course advantage at Lahinch.
The Brits and the Irish and the Scots and the Welsh who make up the GB&I team care way more about the Walker Cup than we do in the States. If we had won, it would have been a yawn in the U.S. and an “of course we beat GB&I, we always beat GB&I.”
But our guys that made up the U.S. team cared. It’s one of those events that makes you care deeply when you’re in the middle of it. Life-long friendships are forged. Hagestad has seen some incredibly talented players raise the U.S. flag at six Walker Cup opening ceremonies.
Smith, Pennsylvania's high school champion as a sophomore at Brookville in 1994, has packed a lifetime of golf memories into a compacted single year in which two Walker Cups were contested with him as the U.S. captain.
But it’s match play, which is as much about grit as it is talent. And on this day, in 10 singles matches, GB&I was the better team and created some Walker Cup magic that will be talked about for a long, long time.