There’s something about the Oceanside Country Club layout in Ormond Beach, Fla. that fits the eye of Kary Hollenbaugh, a junior at Ohio State from New Albany, Ohio.
Oceanside is the home of the venerable South Atlantic Women’s Amateur Championship, known better known by its shorthand moniker, The Sally. We’re talking venerable as in this was the 99th playing of The Sally. The event will celebrate its 100th anniversary next January.
And for the second straight year, Hollenbaugh, No. 56 in the Women’s World Amateur Golf Ranking (WAGR), rolled to the crown in The Sally, a stop on the unofficial Orange Blossom Tour of amateur events for women in Florida in the winter, by the same five-shot margin she did when she dominated the field a year ago. The 72-hole test wrapped up Saturday.
Hollenbaugh has been a solid player in the lineup at Ohio State under Lisa Strom, the 1994 PIAA champion as a senior at Lansdale Catholic and a former Buckeye standout.
But Oceanside brings out the best in Hollenbaugh’s game.
Pretty sure The Sally caught a little of the cold air that descended deep into the eastern half of the country last week, although temperatures in the 60s would feel pretty toasty to those of us shivering in the Northeast. The scores were pretty high, which makes me think the wind was blowing, as it is wont to do in South Florida.
But Hollenbaugh seemed unbothered by any of it. She trailed Kaitlyn Schroeder, the Jacksonville phenom who came home to play under her dad at North Florida after a year at Alabama, by a shot after Hollenbaugh opened with a solid 1-under 71.
But while everybody else was having issues of one kind or another in the middle two rounds Thursday and Friday, Hollenbaugh put together back-to-back 2-under 70s to give herself a seven-shot lead going into Saturday’s final round.
Hollenbaugh matched par in the final round with a 72 for a 5-under 283 total. She was the only player to finish under par for the week.
Hollenbaugh’s closest pursuer was Emma Schimpf, a senior at the College of Charleston from Daniel Island, S.C. Schimpf matched the low round of the week with her sparkling 5-under 67 in Friday’s third round, but that still left her in second place and seven shots behind Hollenbaugh going into Saturday’s final round.
Schimpf closed with a solid 2-under 70 to earn runnerup honors with an even-par 288 total. Schimpf has been a stalwart at the College of Charleston, including an individual crown in the conference championship in 2023 before the Colonial Athletic Association changed its name to the Coastal Athletic Association, the CAA in either case.
Gianna Clemente, the junior phenom from Estero, Fla. who has a pretty good track record in this event herself, including a title in 2023, was another two shots behind Schimpf in third place at 2-over 290 after Clemente fired a sparkling final round of 4-under 68.
Not sure if there was a back-nine start in those first two rounds, but Hollenbaugh took control of the tournament in the second round.
She had bogeys on the first and second holes and then played 4-under golf the rest of the way with birdies at three, four, six and 13. Even if Hollenbaugh started off the 10th tee, she was still 1-under on the incoming nine at Oceanside and bounced right back from the bogeys at the first and second holes with birdies on three of the next four holes.
Hollenbaugh made a birdie on the sixth hole and had eight pars on the outgoing nine to open her third round Friday. After briefly stumbling with back-to-back bogeys at the 10th and 11th holes, Hollenbaugh rattled off birdies at 12, 14 and 18 to expand her lead to seven shots.
Playing with a big lead isn’t always as easy it seems like it should be, but Hollenbaugh managed just fine in Saturday’s final round.
She rebounded from a bogey at the second hole with birdies at four and five. After a bogey at the sixth hole, Hollenbaugh made a birdie at 10, a bogey at 12 and back-to-back birdies at 15 and 16 that afforded her the luxury of a messy double bogey at the last.
Ohio State, a Big Ten power, failed to advance to the NCAA Championship last spring, finishing sixth as a six seed in the Bryan Regional. It’s a new Big Ten this year with Pac-12 ex-pats Southern California, UCLA, Oregon and Washington joining the fray.
Looks like the Big Ten Championship has booked a return date at Bulle Rock, the Havre de Grace, Md. layout that once played host to the LPGA Championship – forebearer of the KPMG Women’s PGA Championship – in April. Some pretty good golf will be on display just outside what is considered the Philadelphia area.
I’m sure Hollenbaugh, who finished in a tie for 10th at Bulle Rock last spring, and Strom, her coach, are hoping the Big Ten Championship is the jumping-off point for a run to the NCAA Championship at the LaCosta Resort & Spa in Carlsbad, Calif. this spring.
Schimpf highlighted the fall campaign of her senior season as she led College of Charleston to the team crown in the Evie Odom Invitational at Princess Anne Country Club by claiming the individual title, the sixth victory of her outstanding college career.
Schimpf struggled early in The Sally, adding a 5-over 77 in Thursday’s second round to her opening-round 74 before finishing strong, going 7-under over the final two rounds to earn runnerup honors.
Clemente, like Hollenbaugh a native Ohioan from Warren, was the runnerup to Hollenbaugh in The Sally a year ago. Like Schimpf, Clemente started slowly, struggling to a 6-over 78 in the opening round before adding a 73 in Thursday’s second round.
But Clemente found her groove in the final two rounds over a golf course that she, too, seems to have an affinity for as she posted a 1-under 71 in Friday’s third round before closing with that 68 that enabled her to finish a shot behind Schimpf in third place.
It’s easy to forget that Clemente is still just a Class of 2026 kid, the equivalent of a high school junior.
She seems to save her best stuff for the U.S. Girls’ Junior Championship, reaching at least the semifinals in each of the last three editions, falling in the final to Oregon sophomore Kiara Romero in the final in 2023 at The Club at Olde Stone in Bowling Green, Ky.
Clemente finished in a tie for fifth place in her second shot at the Augusta National Women’s Amateur Championship last spring and I’m guessing another invitation to that prestigious event is on its way, if it hasn’t arrived already.
There isn’t a college coach in America who wouldn’t want to add Clemente to his or her roster, maybe even as soon as the spring semester of 2026, but her level of play would suggest that going directly to the pro ranks is also being seriously considered. Of course, there is the not small matter of NIL money college programs can offer or that individual players can earn on their own that is changing the equation a little.
Schroeder, the American Junior Golf Association (AJGA) Rolex Player of the Year in 2022, finished a shot behind Clemente in fourth place with a 3-over 291 total.
After taking the lead with her opening-round 70, Schroeder struggled in the middle two rounds, following up a a 4-over 76 in Thursday’s second round with a 75 in Friday’s third round. She finished up with a solid 2-under 70.
Schroeder was one of the most coveted recruits in the country in 2023, but she struggled at Alabama, failing to make the starting lineup in the spring of 2024.
Schroeder will undoubtedly be more comfortable back home at North Florida, where her father Scott is the director of golf for both the men’s and women’s programs.
Karoline Tuttle, a redshirt sophomore at Florida from Lake Mary, Fla., finished a shot behind Schroeder in fifth place with a 4-over 292 total. Tuttle was coming off a two-shot victory in last month’s Women’s Dixie Amateur at Eagle Trace Golf Club in Coral Springs, Fla.
Tuttle struggled in the first two rounds, adding at 6-over 78 in Thursday’s second round to an opening-round 73. But she got it going in the final two rounds, registering a solid 2-under 70 in Friday’s third round before closing with a 71.
Morgan Ketchum, a junior at Virginia Tech from Winston-Salem, N.C., finished two shots behind Tuttle in sixth place with a 6-over 294 total.
Thursday’s second round was the issue for Ketchum, too, as she had opened with a solid 1-under 71 before struggling to an 81. Ketchum bounced back with a 2-under 70 in Friday’s third round before matching par in the final round with a 72.
A couple of youngsters who plan to begin their college careers at the end of the summer, Thanana Kotchasanmanee of Thailand and Katelyn Huber of Gainesville, Ga., shared seventh place, each landing on 7-over 295, a shot behind Ketchum.
Kotchasanmanee, who is headed for Princeton and the Ivy League, matched par in the opening round with a 72 before struggling a little in the middle two rounds with a 4-over 76 in Thursday’s second round and a 74 in Friday’s third round. She closed with a solid 1-over 73.
Huber, who plans to join Tuttle with her home-state Florida Gators in the tough Southeastern Conference this summer, struggled a little early, adding a 4-over 76 in Thursday’s second round to her opening-round 75. But she bounced back with a 1-under 71 in Friday’s third round before matching Kotchasanmanee’s 1-over 73 in the final round.
Clemente isn’t the only Class of ’26 Ohio native with a bright future. Mia Hammond, like Hollenbaugh a New Albany kid, flashed her considerable talent by matching the low round of the week with a sparkling 5-under 67 in Saturday’s final round that enabled her to climb into the top 10 as she finished in ninth place with an 8-over 296 total.
Hammond, who has committed to join the program at Atlantic Coast Conference power Duke in the summer of 2026, teed it up in two LPGA Tour stops in Ohio in the summer of 2023, making the cut and finishing in a tie for 26th place in the Dana Open in Sylvania, Ohio.
Like a lot of players, Hammond struggled in Thursday’s second round, posting an 81 after opening with a 3-over 75. She bounced back with a 1-over 73 in Friday’s third round before finishing with a flourish in the final round.
Rounding out the top 10 was Angela Zhang, another Class of ’26 entry from Bellevue, Wash., as she finished a shot behind Hammond in 10th place with a 9-over 297 total. Zhang, who has committed to join the Big Ten’s Southern California in the summer of 2026, finished strong with a 2-under 70 in the final round.
Avery McCrery, a Wilmington, Del. native, had a pair of top-10 finishes in The Sally the last two years. McCrery, who will join the program at Duke this summer, got off to a good start this year, but struggled a little in the final three rounds to finish among a trio of players tied for 16th place with a 15-over 303 total.
McCrery, coming off a solid tie for ninth place in last month’s Dixie Women’s Amateur at Eagle Trace, matched par in the opening round with a 72 and was just two shots off the pace. She added a 4-over 76 in Thursday’s second round and a 75 in Friday’s third round before closing with an 80.
A couple of interesting names in the group tied for 16th with McCrery were Alice Ziyi Zhao, a Class of ’27 competitor from China, and Grace Lu, a redshirt junior at Rutgers from Edison, N.J.
Ziyi Zhao earned official phenom status when she burst onto the scene by earning a share of medalist honors in qualifying for match play in the 2022 U.S. Women’s Amateur at Chambers Bay as a 13-year-old. After opening with a 5-over 77 at Oceanside, Ziyi Zhao sandwiched a 78 in Friday’s third round with a pair of 74s in Thursday’s second round and Saturday’s final round.
Grace Lu, who began her college career at William & Mary before transferring to Rutgers and the Big Ten, got off to a solid start with a 1-over 73 and added a 75 in the second round before struggling in the final two rounds with a 77 in Friday’s third round and a 78 in Saturday’s final round.
Grace Lu’s younger sister Claire Lu, coming off a really nice start to her college career in the Ivy League with Penn in the fall, finished alone in 33rd place in The Sally with a 22-over 310 total.
I never caught up with the Penn women’s team in the fall, but the Quakers claimed a pair of team titles with Claire Lu leading the way in the victory in the Quinnipiac Classic by capturing the first individual crown of her collegiate career at the Farms Country Club in Wallingford, Conn.
Claire Lu got off to a tough start at Oceanside, adding an 80 in the second round to her opening-round 79, but she kept battling, recording a 3-over 75 in Friday’s third round before finishing up with a 76.
In The Sally’s Rockefeller Division, Chris Hunt of Sawgrass Country Club outdueled Barbara Pagana, winner of the Super Senior division in last summer’s Pennsylvania Women’s Amateur Championship at Sunnybrook Golf Club, by two shots to capture the title with a 31-over 247 total.
Hunt sandwiched an 87 in Thursday’s second round with a pair of 80s in the 54-hole Rockefeller Division, which wrapped up Friday.
Pagana, who plays out of Huntsville Golf Club, kept the pressure on Hunt the whole way. Pagana’s opening-round 84 left her four shots behind Hunt. Pagana cut her deficit to three shots with an 86 in Thursday’s second round and closed with a solid 79 to finish two shots behind Hunt with a 249 total.
It wouldn’t be a Sally without Merion Golf Club’s Liz Haines in the field and the ageless Haines finished in seventh place in the Rockefeller Division with a 270 total.
Haines was coming off a tie for 10th place in the Forever 49 Division in the Citrus Golf Trail Ladies Invitational at the Sun ’n Lake Golf Club in Sebring, Fla., which wrapped on New Year’s Eve. At Oceanside, Haines opened with an 86 and added a 93 in Thursday’s second round before closing with a 91.